By Andrew L. Jaffee
Fareed Zakaria is a man I respect — his ideas are always worth considering. But in a recent Newsweek column, he argues for President Bush’s guest worker/amnesty program, legislation that I believe would undermine America’s prosperity and democracy.
First, Zakaria draws an analogy between: a) the positive influence that Indian immigrants have had on American society; and, b) the unrelenting flow of Latinos into the U.S. This analogy is flawed. Indian immigrants are generally highly-skilled and come from a nation with a long tradition of democracy. Latino immigrants are mostly unskilled, and come from societies dominated above all by corruption (e.g., Mexico; remember that the PRI ruled Mexico rather undemocratically until only a few years ago).
Parenthetically, have you ever heard of East Indian gangs terrorizing America’s streets? On the other hand, Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13) is considered the “most dangerous gang in America.”
Second, Zakaria frames our immigration problem mostly in terms of economic supply and demand — supply being a pool of cheap Latin labor, and demand being America’s insatiable appetite for services. While not scientific, I can travel to my hometown’s inner city neighborhoods and easily point out scads of Americans out of work — or unwilling to work. This city’s unemployment rate was 6.7 and 6.1 for the first 2 months of 2006, respectively. That’s about 2 percent above the national average, and the city’s demography is not by any means predominantly Latino. Why can’t these people be employed? This is a societal problem not to be solved by importing Mexico’s unemployed, but by tackling faults in our education system, and requiring citizens to assume personal responsibility for their actions.
Here’s Zakaria’s thesis:
The United States has a real problem with illegal-immigrant flows, largely from Mexico (70 percent of illegal immigrants are from that one country). But let us understand the forces at work here. “The income gap between the United States and Mexico is the largest between any two contiguous countries in the world,” writes Stanford historian David Kennedy. That huge disparity is producing massive demand in the United States and massive supply from Mexico and Central America. Whenever governments try to come between these two forces-think of drugs-simply increasing enforcement does not work. Tighter border control is an excellent idea, but to work it will have to be coupled with some recognition of the laws of supply and demand-that is, it will have to include expansion of the legal-immigrant pool.
We’re way past the point of granting amnesty to illegals — about 12 million (illegal immigrants) past that point. Assimilation takes time. When does the U.S. become unmanageable? When the population reaches 400, 500, 600 million? How do we educate and assimilate unskilled immigrants at the current, rapid pace of influx?
Take action. Support LEGAL immigration.
(more…)